Ideal Weight Formulas Compared: Devine, Robinson, Miller and Hamwi

Where the four best-known ideal body weight formulas came from, how they differ, worked examples for men and women, and their limits.

Ideal body weight (IBW) formulas give a single target weight for a given height and sex. Four of them are widely used: Hamwi, Devine, Robinson and Miller. They give similar but not identical answers, because each was built in a different way and for a different purpose.

Our ideal weight calculator shows all four side by side for your height.

Try the Ideal Weight Calculator. Ideal body weight by four formulas and BMI range

Open the calculator

The four formulas

Each one starts from a base weight at 5 feet (152.4 cm) and adds a fixed amount for every inch above that.

Formula Year Men Women
Hamwi 1964 48.0 kg + 2.7 kg/inch 45.5 kg + 2.2 kg/inch
Devine 1974 50.0 kg + 2.3 kg/inch 45.5 kg + 2.3 kg/inch
Robinson 1983 52.0 kg + 1.9 kg/inch 49.0 kg + 1.7 kg/inch
Miller 1983 56.2 kg + 1.41 kg/inch 53.1 kg + 1.36 kg/inch

Where each came from

Hamwi (1964) was proposed by G. J. Hamwi as a quick rule of thumb for estimating ideal weight, mainly in the context of diabetes care. It was originally given in pounds: 106 lb for a 5-foot man plus 6 lb per inch, and 100 lb for a woman plus 5 lb per inch.

Devine (1974) was published by B. J. Devine to help calculate doses of the antibiotic gentamicin. Despite that narrow origin, it became the most widely used IBW formula in medicine, especially for drug dosing and setting ventilator volumes.

Robinson (1983) and Miller (1983) were both attempts to fit the formula more closely to data from life insurance height and weight tables. They produce flatter lines, meaning they rise less steeply with height.

Advertisement

Worked examples

A woman who is 5 ft 4 in (4 inches over 5 feet)

Formula Ideal weight
Hamwi 54.3 kg (120 lb)
Devine 54.7 kg (121 lb)
Robinson 55.8 kg (123 lb)
Miller 58.5 kg (129 lb)

Healthy BMI range at this height: about 48.9 to 65.8 kg.

A man who is 6 ft 0 in (12 inches over 5 feet)

Formula Ideal weight
Miller 73.1 kg (161 lb)
Robinson 74.8 kg (165 lb)
Devine 77.6 kg (171 lb)
Hamwi 80.4 kg (177 lb)

Healthy BMI range at this height: about 61.9 to 83.3 kg.

How they compare

  • Hamwi rises fastest with height, so it gives the highest values for tall people.
  • Miller rises slowest, so it gives the highest values for short people and the lowest for tall people.
  • Devine and Robinson fall in between.
  • All four fall inside the healthy BMI range for most adult heights.

Limitations

  • One number for everyone. None of the formulas account for frame size, muscle mass or age.
  • Built on limited data. They reflect mid-20th-century populations and, in Devine's case, a dosing need rather than health outcomes.
  • Below 5 feet, the straight-line formulas become unreliable.
  • Not health targets. Being a few kilograms above or below any of these numbers says little about your health on its own.

For personal goals, the healthy BMI range, combined with waist size and overall health, is usually a better guide. We explain why in ideal weight vs healthy weight range.

This guide is general information, not medical advice. Talk to a doctor, midwife or registered dietitian about your own situation.