The Limitations of BMI (and What to Use Alongside It)

Why BMI can misjudge athletes, older adults and different ethnic groups, and which other measures give a fuller picture of health.

Body mass index is one of the most widely used health measures in the world. It is quick, free and needs only a scale and a tape measure. But it is a rough tool. It was designed to study weight across large populations, not to judge one person's health.

You can still find your BMI with our BMI calculator. This guide explains when to take the result with a pinch of salt.

Try the BMI Calculator. Body mass index and healthy weight range

Open the calculator

A short history

BMI comes from work by the Belgian mathematician Adolphe Quetelet in the 1830s, who looked at the relationship between weight and height across populations. It was renamed "body mass index" in a 1972 study by the American physiologist Ancel Keys, who found it was a reasonable population-level indicator of body fat. It was adopted widely because it was simple.

What BMI misses

Muscle vs fat

BMI uses total weight, and muscle is denser than fat. A muscular athlete can have a BMI in the overweight range while carrying little body fat. Rugby players, weightlifters and sprinters often fall into this group.

Where fat is stored

Fat around the abdomen, especially around the organs, is more closely linked to type 2 diabetes and heart disease than fat on the hips and thighs. Two people with the same BMI can have very different fat distribution, and very different risks.

Age

Older adults tend to lose muscle and bone mass. Someone can have a "healthy" BMI while having relatively high body fat and low muscle, a combination linked to frailty.

Ethnic background

People of South Asian, Chinese and some other backgrounds tend to have higher health risks at a lower BMI. Some health bodies recommend lower thresholds for these groups. See the BMI chart for adults for the figures.

Sex

At the same BMI, women on average carry more body fat than men. The categories are the same for both.

Height

BMI divides by height squared, which slightly favors shorter people and penalizes taller people, because body volume does not scale exactly with the square of height.

Advertisement

Measures to use alongside BMI

Measure What it adds How to check
Waist circumference Shows abdominal fat Tape measure around the waist, midway between the lowest rib and the top of the hip bone
Waist-to-height ratio Abdominal fat relative to height Waist divided by height; under 0.5 is a common target
Body fat percentage Separates fat from lean mass Tape method, smart scales, or a DEXA scan
Blood pressure, blood sugar, cholesterol Direct markers of health risk Routine checks with a doctor
Fitness Strongly linked to long-term health Walking speed, stair climbing, exercise tests

Our body fat calculator uses the US Navy tape method to estimate body fat from a few measurements.

Waist-to-height ratio

A simple rule used by several health bodies is to keep your waist measurement to less than half your height. Someone 170 cm tall would aim for a waist under 85 cm. It is easy to remember and picks up abdominal fat that BMI can miss.

So is BMI useless?

No. For most adults, BMI gives a reasonable first indication, and at a population level it tracks health risks well. Its problems show up mainly at the edges: very muscular people, older adults, and different ethnic groups. Used as a starting point and combined with other measures, it remains helpful.

If your BMI suggests a problem, or seems wrong for your build, talk to a doctor, who can assess your health more completely.

This guide is general information, not medical advice. Talk to a doctor, midwife or registered dietitian about your own situation.